Favouritism, Cronyism and the Abuse of Power in Church Leadership

What Does the Letter of James Teach Us About Favouritism?

The Church is called to be a place of truth, fairness, humility and integrity. Those entrusted with leadership carry a particularly important responsibility to demonstrate these values, not only through their preaching but also through their decisions and conduct.

Unfortunately, churches are not immune to favouritism, cronyism or the misuse of authority. When church leaders use their positions to benefit themselves or their closest associates, serious questions arise about whether their decisions reflect biblical principles or personal interests.

The letter of James provides one of the clearest warnings in the New Testament against favouritism.

James 2:1 (NIV) states:

“My brothers and sisters, believers in our glorious Lord Jesus Christ must not show favouritism.”

James makes it clear that showing favouritism is incompatible with the Christian faith. His teaching challenges believers to examine how they treat others, particularly when decisions are influenced by wealth, status, personal relationships or positions of authority.

Although James uses the example of preferential treatment towards wealthy people, the underlying principle extends much further. It challenges every situation where individuals receive special treatment because of who they are or whom they know.

This is especially relevant when considering appointments to positions of church leadership.

When Discernment Becomes a Convenient Excuse

Consider the fictional scenario illustrated in the accompanying cartoons.

A pastor announces to his congregation that the appointment of another pastor to the pastoral team requires considerable spiritual discernment.

He explains that the leadership must carefully consider the appointment, seek God’s guidance, pray and take whatever time is necessary to reach the correct decision.

The process, he insists, could take weeks and weeks.

As time passes, the pastor continues to emphasise how difficult the decision is and how much spiritual consideration is required.

Eventually, he announces that the leadership has reached its decision.

The successful candidate is his best mate.

The congregation is then informed that, after all the careful consideration and discernment, the person chosen to join the pastoral team just happens to be the pastor’s closest friend.

The pastor certainly was a happy chappy.

The final cartoon depicts the pastor and his best mate running towards the bank, with the pastor shouting, “You’re in the Club!”

Was the appointment genuinely the result of impartial spiritual discernment, or was the process used to justify a decision that benefited the pastor and his closest friend?

The fact that a pastor’s best mate is appointed does not automatically mean wrongdoing has occurred. He may be genuinely called, appropriately qualified and entirely suitable for the position.

However, when a leader has influence over a process that could directly benefit a close personal friend, there is an obvious conflict of interest that must be addressed openly and responsibly.

Spiritual language must never become a convenient way of avoiding scrutiny.

What Is Cronyism in Church Leadership?

Cronyism occurs when individuals receive preferential treatment, opportunities or appointments because of close personal friendships or connections rather than being assessed fairly on their suitability and qualifications.

Within a church, cronyism can arise when pastors or senior leaders influence decisions that benefit their closest friends, family or associates.

Examples might include appointing close friends to paid church positions without a fair selection process, overlooking more suitable candidates, or allowing personal friends to exercise authority without proper accountability.

There is nothing inherently wrong with close friends serving together in church leadership. Throughout Christian history, friendships have played an important role in ministry and Christian service.

The problem begins when personal friendships influence decisions that should be made impartially, transparently and in the best interests of the Church.

If a pastor is involved in selecting his best mate for a paid leadership position, the congregation is entitled to expect appropriate safeguards.

Who assessed the candidate’s suitability? Were other candidates considered? Was the pastor excluded from decisions where personal interests could influence the outcome? Was the appointment independently reviewed?

These are reasonable questions, not attacks on the Christian faith.

James Warns That Favouritism Is Sin

James does not treat favouritism as a minor weakness or an unfortunate aspect of human behaviour.

He directly identifies it as sinful.

James 2:9 (NIV) states:

“But if you show favouritism, you sin”

This is a powerful statement.

James teaches that favouritism is not simply poor judgement. It is contrary to the standards Christians are called to uphold.

If church leaders apply one standard to ordinary members of the congregation but another to their close friends, they risk violating this principle.

If opportunities are offered to personal friends without the same scrutiny applied to others, the fairness of the process becomes questionable.

And if spiritual discernment is presented as the justification for a decision that was influenced by personal friendships, the problem becomes even more serious.

A church cannot credibly preach against favouritism while allowing preferential treatment to influence its own leadership appointments.

Church Leadership Must Never Become a Position of Personal Advantage

Jesus taught that Christian leadership should be characterised by service rather than personal power.

In Mark 10:42–45 (NIV), Jesus contrasts worldly rulers, who exercise authority over others, with the servant leadership expected of His followers. He teaches that greatness among His disciples is found in serving others, following His own example of selfless service.

His teaching challenges the idea that positions of authority exist to provide privilege, influence or financial advantage.

A pastor is entrusted with responsibility for the spiritual welfare of the congregation. That responsibility should never become an opportunity to establish a leadership structure dominated by personal friends or secure preferential benefits for those closest to him.

The fictional cartoon showing the pastor and his best mate running towards the bank is deliberately humorous. Nevertheless, it illustrates a legitimate concern about personal favouritism and the potential misuse of church finances.

If a pastor influences the appointment of his closest friend to a paid position, the decision may provide that friend with financial benefits and greater influence within the church.

That benefit does not, by itself, establish that the appointment was improper. However, the close friendship creates a potential conflict of interest that must be declared and managed.

The congregation should be confident that church funds are being used responsibly and that appointments are made for the right reasons.

Church leadership is a responsibility to serve others, not a privilege to be exploited for personal gain or to reward close friends.

Biblical Qualifications Must Come Before Personal Connections

The Apostle Paul provides important guidance concerning the character expected of church leaders.

In 1 Timothy 3:1–7 and Titus 1:5–9 (NIV), Paul identifies qualities including self-control, good character, hospitality, integrity and the ability to teach. He also emphasises that leaders must not be driven by greed or be overbearing in their conduct.

These passages emphasise spiritual maturity and personal conduct.

They do not suggest that someone should receive a leadership position simply because they are the pastor’s closest friend.

Neither do they establish that being a close friend of a church leader automatically disqualifies someone from serving.

Instead, they reinforce the importance of examining a person’s character, suitability and ability to fulfil the responsibilities of leadership.

A fair process should place these considerations above personal friendships.

The question should never be, “Who is the pastor’s best mate?”

It should be, “Who is genuinely suitable, biblically qualified and called to serve in this position?”

The Danger of Using Spiritual Authority to Silence Questions

One of the most troubling aspects of favouritism in church leadership is the possibility that spiritual language may be used to discourage legitimate questions.

When a pastor announces that a decision has been reached through prayer and discernment, congregation members may understandably hesitate to challenge it.

They may fear being accused of questioning God’s will, undermining church unity or disrespecting spiritual authority.

However, the claim that a decision was prayerfully discerned does not place that decision beyond examination.

1 Thessalonians 5:21 (NIV) instructs believers:

“but test them all; hold on to what is good”

Christians are encouraged to exercise judgement and examine what they are told.

Healthy church leadership should welcome appropriate questions, particularly when appointments involve close personal friendships, financial interests or the exercise of authority.

A genuinely transparent process should be able to withstand reasonable scrutiny.

If leaders respond to legitimate concerns with defensiveness, intimidation or accusations of disloyalty, this can damage trust within the congregation.

Accountability is not rebellion. It is an important safeguard against the misuse of power.

The Damage Favouritism Can Cause to a Congregation

When members of a congregation believe leadership appointments are influenced by personal friendships rather than fairness, the consequences can be significant.

Trust in church leadership may deteriorate. Dedicated volunteers may feel overlooked. Potential leaders may become discouraged if they believe opportunities are reserved for a small circle of close friends, family and associates.

Some members may eventually leave the church because they no longer have confidence in the integrity of its leadership.

The damage can extend beyond the immediate congregation.

A church that publicly teaches biblical standards while appearing to disregard those standards internally risks undermining its Christian witness.

James reminds believers that faith must be demonstrated through conduct, not merely expressed through words.

This principle is developed throughout James 2:14–26 (NIV), where James explains that genuine faith is accompanied by action and that a profession of faith without corresponding deeds is insufficient.

The same principle applies to church leadership.

It is not enough to preach fairness, humility and integrity. Those qualities must be evident in the way decisions are made.

How Should Churches Prevent Favouritism and Cronyism?

Churches should establish clear and accountable procedures for appointing pastors and other senior leaders.

Where a candidate is a close personal friend of an existing leader, the relationship should be declared openly. The connected leader should not control the selection process or decisions concerning the candidate’s appointment, salary or conditions of employment.

Independent assessment, documented selection criteria and appropriate oversight can help protect both the church and the candidate from accusations of unfairness.

The congregation should also receive sufficient information to understand how important leadership decisions have been reached, while respecting legitimate confidentiality.

These safeguards do not undermine spiritual discernment.

They strengthen it by ensuring that prayerful decision-making is accompanied by integrity, transparency and accountability.

Conclusion: God’s Church Must Not Become a Private Members’ Club

The cartoons illustrate an uncomfortable possibility: a lengthy process of supposed spiritual discernment could be used to legitimise an appointment that benefits someone already closely connected to those holding power.

They are satire, not proof that any particular appointment was improper. Nevertheless, the underlying warning deserves serious consideration.

When church leaders appoint their closest family members, colleagues and especially friends to paid positions, they must recognise the potential for favouritism, cronyism and conflicts of interest.

The letter of James leaves little room for preferential treatment based on personal status or relationships.

James 2:9 explicitly condemns favouritism, while the teachings of Jesus remind us that leadership is about service rather than personal advantage.

A pastor’s best mate may be an excellent candidate for pastoral ministry. But his appointment should be demonstrably fair, properly assessed and free from inappropriate influence by his close friend.

The ultimate test of spiritual discernment is not how many weeks a leadership team spends discussing an appointment, or how often it claims to have prayed about the decision.

It is whether the decision has been reached with biblical integrity, impartiality, transparency and genuine accountability.

The Church belongs to Christ. It must never become a private members’ club where those in authority use their positions to advance the interests of their closest friends at the expense of fairness and trust.

As James teaches, favouritism has no rightful place among those who profess faith in Jesus Christ.